Please help me choose a logo design



Good idea, I have been thru logo hell, 9 different designers and still nothing I like, this looks like a good service. 100 for me too..
 
Kudos op on the number of search listings for your website name. Despite your site having an "under construction" facial you are getting some nice links off of this.

Intentional or not good play on the logo contest. At first glance can't tell how fast you indexed for those links but it looks tight. I will be trying this.

Guessing other people besides me do not know what your site is about. As far as the logo graphics go 2 bots trading tongues might be great for a dating site, not so good if it is a porta-john company. Maybe the highest vote count is not the real winner depending on the sites intention?
 
85 looks like two gay monsters blowing each other



NI7Ql.jpg
 
At least you got a few decent original choices. Any time I've used 99designs I get shitty designs that I could make myself in 2 minutes. Any hints on how to structure your contest to attract REAL designers on that stupid site? Do you just offer more $$$ ??
 
Man I'm sorry but I took another look, none of them are up to par imho....
I have been thru logo hell as I mentioned, look at my site, this was the best I could come up with with 9 different designers, many of them I personally met and nice people
biggesttrainwreck.com

For your loyalty program, I am thinking of some kind of loyal pet (dog?) who brings back the paper and is patted on the head, maybe dog is bringing money roll instead of paper, rewarded by owner....

A lot of these logos just look too clean, spiffed, photoshopped, need something that stirs the emotions.....