1 month, $10,000 profit all ppc challenge

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sheesh, he just started the campaign! Why are some surprised by this? He made a profit on the first swing at bat ... which is a great sign and means it can be tweaked for even a greater ROI once the bad performing keywords are deleted and the ad copy is tested some more.

Rarely, if ever, does a campaign's ROI peak at first launch... it's a testing process the whole way through. Which is exactly why the majority of people FAIL to make money online .... they can't handle the bumps in the road and don't know what to do when they get there.

In general, you are more then right! This is how you should approach ppc...
Personally though, I test campaigns for 1-2 days and if they not doing well, I move on to other campaigns who will be (more) profitable. Again, that's how I approach things. :)
 


I've got 3 different payouts to deal with. So, the way I handle this is to take an average of the 3 payouts and use that average as my payout for all calculations. In this case I have one that pays $150, $60 and $40 so the average is $83.33. So I can spend $83 to get a lead. That's my starting point. Now I know whenever a keyword hits the $83 mark and is not profitable, I have to either delete/pause or adjust the bid downward.

If the keyword has converted, I will know the conversion rate, so I can apply the following formula to figure out the new bid:

New Bid = Target Max Cost x Conversion Rate

So let's say I have found a keyword that has converted but has cost me $112 for one conversion, so I know it's above my target max cost. This means I have to do something and that is lower the bid to a point where it will be profitable if I get a conversion. Let's assume it converted at 1.33% for an example. My calculation is as follows:

New Bid = $83 x 0.0133
New Bid = $1.11

So I go into whichever engine I'm working on and adjust the bid for that converter down to $1.11. NOW if that keyword converts at that conversion rate, (it may or may not, but let's assume it does), I know I'll be making at least 100% ROI and that's exactly what I want. But what about keywords that have not converted but have gone over the $83 mark? The answer is easy delete or pause that keyword. It hasn't worked yet and yes you may hit a miracle click, but why waste money on it. Just delete or pause it and move along, there are literally millions of other keywords out there.

Can we check those calculations again? Maybe I'm figuring this wrong, but if your average payout is $83, and you are converting at 1.33%, then that new bid of $1.11 would not give you a 100% ROI - it would be your break-even point.

Now, on a bid of $.55 for 75 clicks, that's a spend of 41.25 and a profit of 83 - that's your 100% ROI...
 
Can we check those calculations again? Maybe I'm figuring this wrong, but if your average payout is $83, and you are converting at 1.33%, then that new bid of $1.11 would not give you a 100% ROI - it would be your break-even point.

Now, on a bid of $.55 for 75 clicks, that's a spend of 41.25 and a profit of 83 - that's your 100% ROI...

No. If you invest $50, and your return is $50, (revenue $50, profit 0). Your return on investment (ROI) is 100% of your investment. Which is the same thing as break even.
 
No. If you invest $50, and your return is $50, (revenue $50, profit 0). Your return on investment (ROI) is 100% of your investment. Which is the same thing as break even.

Sorry, but that's wrong. Return is profit. 100% ROI means that you've doubled your money.

In finance, rate of return (ROR) or return on investment (ROI), or sometimes just return, is the ratio of money gained or lost on an investment relative to the amount of money invested. The amount of money gained or lost may be referred to as interest, profit/loss, gain/loss, or net income/loss. The money invested may be referred to as the asset, capital, principal, or the cost basis of the investment.

from:

Rate of return - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Just a bit of hairsplitting on my side, since you actually understand how it works, but still, the definition just says something else.
 
Sorry, but that's wrong. Return is profit. 100% ROI means that you've doubled your money.



from:

Rate of return - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Just a bit of hairsplitting on my side, since you actually understand how it works, but still, the definition just says something else.


Yeah, I'm not splitting hairs on definitions either - I'm assuming bejeebers is not trying to break even since the name of the thread is "10,000 profit" Not "spend 10,000 and hope I break even". Just wanted to make sure he wasn't using the same calculation on his own spreadsheet, or this whole thread will be a sad, but funny one at the end of the month...
 
Agreed.

Profit = Revenue - Expense
ROI = Revenue / Expense

If your ROI is 100%, you doubled your money spent.
One slight change to that:

ROI = Profit / Expense

But you're right if you hit 100%, you have doubled your money. Which is my goal with this whole thing.

Not much has happened to talk about, just adding more keywords, testing some new adcopy and deleting crap. Plus I did make a slight change to my landing page adding in an example of how the process works to make it crystal clear. I'll see how that turns out...

Here's the numbers, getting there:

stats3.jpg
 
do you have stats on which ppc company has higher conversions? you may want to consider raising your cpc for adwords. just a suggestion though...
 
I just finished increasing all my bids for adwords. That should get alot more clicks. I also just changed my ads a bit so we'll see how that does.

I think I may have gone a bit too low to start with them, I am getting some clicks but not a high enough volume for my liking.
 
Yea, I bet that will help some. Its always hard to find the middle ground between volume and return on investment. Good luck, though, you seem to be on the right track with everything.
 
No. If you invest $50, and your return is $50, (revenue $50, profit 0). Your return on investment (ROI) is 100% of your investment. Which is the same thing as break even.

I hear different opinions all the time...
By ROI 100% I mean you spend $1 and get back $2!
If you spend $1 and get back the same amount of revenue $1, then ROI is 0%. You should go for at least ROI 100%, then you do well. ROI 50% can be still acceptable depending on offers and other factors! :)
 
ROI means return on investment.

If you spend $1 and get back $1 you broke even. (ROI is 0%)

If you spend $1 and get back $2 you doubled your money. (ROI is 100%)

The calculation is:

Profit = Revenue - Expense

So,

Profit = $2 - $1
Profit = $1

ROI% = (Profit/Expense) x 100
ROI% = ($1/$1) x 100
ROI% = (1) x 100
ROI% = 100%

Say we want to figure out what kind of expense we can have if we know we want a certain ROI:

For example: Target ROI 134%

Expense = 1/Target ROI
Expense = 1/1.34
Expense = 0.75 *rounded off

So we know we can spend $0.75 to get an ROI of 134% in this case.

Check:

ROI% = (Profit/Expense) x 100
ROI% = (1/0.75) x 100
ROI% = 133.33 *off a bit due to rounding

So that's your math lesson for today kiddies. Now go make some money.
 
Last edited:
Ok I must believe you all :D . And it's sure more logical too. I was just so pretty damn sure it was the unlogical way. ^^
And btw, beejeebers, great profits!
 
ROI means return on investment.

If you spend $1 and get back $1 you broke even. (ROI is 0%)

If you spend $1 and get back $2 you doubled your money. (ROI is 100%)

The calculation is:

Profit = Revenue / Expense

So,

Profit = $2/$1
Profit = $1

ROI% = (Profit/Expense) x 100
ROI% = ($1/$1) x 100
ROI% = (1) x 100
ROI% = 100%

Say we want to figure out what kind of expense we can have if we know we want a certain ROI:

For example: Target ROI 134%

Expense = 1/Target ROI
Expense = 1/1.34
Expense = 0.75 *rounded off

So we know we can spend $0.75 to get an ROI of 134% in this case.

Check:

ROI% = (Profit/Expense) x 100
ROI% = (1/0.75) x 100
ROI% = 133.33 *off a bit due to rounding

So that's your math lesson for today kiddies. Now go make some money.

haha I needed this ROI talk, I've read both ways of doing it but was not sure which way most people do it, I've always done it this way because the other way just seems harder to deal with. Its good to see more people calculate it like I do.
 
Profit = Revenue / Expense


wtf????


profit = rev - exp

roi = (profit/exp) * 100

roi = 0 if you break even, end of story.
 
Profit = Revenue / Expense


wtf????


profit = rev - exp

roi = (profit/exp) * 100

roi = 0 if you break even, end of story.
You're right I had a "/" instead of a "-" sign in there, I fixed it now. (I do that all the time when coding too and it drives me nuts sometimes when debugging the scripts...)
Are you tracking conversions? What does the ROI for the big 3 search engines look like?

Of course I'm tracking conversions. If you don't track conversions, you may as well flush all your money down the toilet!

Here's how it looks:

1% Adwords
50% Overture
49% MSN Adcenter

The niche I'm in, (debt management) is closely related to the loan niche and specifically debt consolidation. So the keywords on adwords are quite expensive. If you don't get an awesome ratio on your landing site, you're screwed. Once my long tail stuff starts producing in adwords, I should be able to blow through the 100% target.
 
I didn't word my question properly. I meant to ask if you were tracking ROI across each different search engine. In other words, how are the different search engines performing for you (return on investment)
 
I see what you mean now. I am keeping track, but would have to go back and total everything up. Generally speaking MSN has the best roi, (and lowest traffic volume). Overture is second best roi and adwords is my lowest roi. There's tons of reasons for it, but the main one is adwords just won't produce for me yet on this project. I'm up against companies that make a lot more per conversion then I do, (companies running their own ppc programs), and they can easily out bid me and still make a great roi. So I have to be creative and find some golden nuggets. The thing is I haven't found any yet in adwords and the ones that are converting on overture and msn, don't necessarily convert on adwords. (I've always found that strange).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.