He served me well too, and I m not sure how he was gaming BST. If he was gaming indeed them I m cool, but maybe it has something to do with the IP.. He is from Pakistan and maybe he was sharing IP because their ISP allot one IP or something..
Maybe you can give him a chance, as I see that a lot of people are vouching for him... He was one of the better providers of dofollow comments...
I can provide him enough work myself, and for cheap as his source of work is gone, but I don't want to be unfair, and I think he might also have been caught in the crossfire...
You may want to crosscheck login times, browser or some other stuff other than the IP...
But It's actually upto you.. I thought I will pitch in too.
Also, if you can list all the member who were sharing the IP, maybe some of us can cross verify the Paypal address..