This is always a question that pops up when negotiating a price point for the leads. You really need to start at a baseline price and be up front with the advertiser/buyer that the baseline/starting price is just that - a starting price. Depending on how the leads back out for the advertiser/buyer the CPL price can go up or down. People need to understand that everybody needs to make money starting from the buyers all the way downstream to the affiliate. Some affiliates have the misconception that they should be paid a huge amount for a lead no matter if the lead sells to the buyer for that amount or not - you are completely wrong.
We negotiate with advertisers/buyers all the time and we usually negotiate on the high side to start out. We tell them we will run a cap of say 500 leads a day for X amount of days. The amount of days will depend on how long it takes them to tell if the quality is backing out. The vertical will depend on how long it takes them to know if the quality backs out. If you are not working with some sketchy advertiser they will adjust your payout (up/down) according to the price they are selling the leads to the buyers. If they are not doing this or you are not negotiating this up front then you are not handling business right.
$1 per lead sounds low for anything. The lowest for a unique hot lead generated should be $3 a lead and that is on the extreme low side. You have to factor in not every lead is going to turn into a sale but once the advertiser/buyer has the consumers info and demographic they can try and sell them other offers as well. Bottom line is make sure you are working with a reputable advertiser/buyer and negotiate from the beginning and always get things signed via a legal contractual agreement.
If you don't have the experience to negotiate with whomever you are dealing with hit me up and we can handle the negotiation with you and you can work through us. Obviously we will take a margin off the top but you won't get jacked around and our biz dev team is very aggressive in negotiating and have a lot of experience doing it. If you think you can handle it yourself just don't shortchange yourself, control the conversation, control the negotiation, and overall you need to play the role of the boss.
Again, if you need some help hit me up and we can handle the business side of it for you and get you the best CPL. Obviously only hit me up if you are doing volume or can do volume because 10-20 leads a day isn't going to be worth anybody's time.
Brian