Holy Shit at the 65% Conversion Rate

Status
Not open for further replies.

fm1234

WF Mega Premium Member
Sep 8, 2007
1,405
63
0
Wow, what a nice week ... shame that it's already dried up and too small a sample upon which to base an efficacy judgment.

I was digging through the mail a couple of weeks ago, all the usual stuff, and was stopped short in my driveway by the Musician's Friend catalogue, which has this gorgeous picture of a Les Paul Vintage Mahogany on the cover. I don't even particularly like the guitar but it got me to stop and think. Someone is being paid to determine what products go on the cover of catalogues. Chances are they know more than I do about their product lines. Maybe I should listen to them.

I set up a landing page which featured a very nice pic of the LPVM and ran some ads on AdWords targeting the specific product, figuring that there would be at least some small spike in search volume as MF mailing list members went looking for info on the guitar. I only got 20 clicks on my ad, but 13 of them converted to sales. Not all of them bought the featured guitar, not all of them bought a guitar at all -- one bought something cheap as hell, maybe strings or a strap or something, as the commission was very low -- but WOW. 20 clicks = 13 sales is not something I've seen in a long, long time.

Will continue to try to duplicate this with other catalogues and see what happens. The key points, as far as I can tell, are:

1) Specific product getting all of the attention on the cover of the catalouge. Something with branding and recognition already built in, so stay away from eg. Hammacher Schlemmer or Nieman Marcus and other specialty places.

2) You must be able to quickly find a good aff. program for that product if you don't already have one.

3) In my case, I made a nice looking splash page with some pictures I got off of the Gibson website and reviews that I wrote based on reviews at Musician's Friend and other sites. The reviews peeked just over the first fold, and the buy it now button just over the second (after the reviews.) About, Contact and Privacy links way the hell down at the bottom -- no other nav or content on the page.

Anyway, will try again and see if this wasn't just an insane fluke. Obviously a 65% conversion rate is probably not going to happen everyday, but I've always been a big believer in letting big companies pay smart people to think about product promotion for me, eg. getting niche ideas from the "New Releases" section of the "Dummies guide" website. And having the people who put together catalogues at some insane rate of pay give me the inspiration on specific products to promote seems like a pretty good idea.


Frank
 


What affiliate program did you use for a guitar? Ebay affiliate perhaps?

Great read!
 
How much did the 20 clicks cost?
How much revenue did the 13 sales bring in?

$22.80 for the clicks, vs. $104.00 in commissions.

What affiliate program did you use for a guitar?

Musician's Friend via CJ. They have a great program and are of course one of if not the leading place online for musical instruments and accessories.


Frank
 
These is the type of stories that make WF a great resource. Obviously most people aren't going to copy this campaign word for word as you wrote it but it gets the wheels turning for other verticals and can start a good flow & exchange of ideas.

Thanks for the post Frank.
 
Can you give a screenshot of the landing page you used?

Ugg. I think these stupid "can I see your biz" comments/question combined with the 1 post wonder should call for an auto ban (and I don't mean the roadway in Germany. )

Anyway, FM what a unique idea. I don't get catalogues but you could probably look for some one line too.
 
I've seen something similar as well. It's a product that is slowly becoming illegal in more and more states(this is seo traffic, not ppc). I thought all my sites for it were dead, until one day another state banned it. 43 sales off that bitch in one day, for sites I (thought) were already dead. Definitely not ranking. 50% conversion.
I can't wait until the next state does that.
 
Thanks for all of the responses to this btw ... regarding "show me your lp" ... without wanting to flame you even more, for me actually stating 1) what I promoted, 2) what strategy I used, 3) exactly how much it cost and made is by far the most detailed I've ever gotten on a non case study post. I don't normally talk about my *niches* let alone specific campain ideas. However, this lp was nothing fancy and you could build a better one in about twelve seconds.

1) Picture of product

2) Rounded corner frame for picture and review section using Spiffy Corners - Purely CSS Rounded Corners

3) There was a queer off-white background in the product image so I made the background colour as close to the same as I could get it and went for a light earth tone on the borders (the product itself is brown.)

4) A handful of reviews cobbled together from reviews at the Musician's Friend site.

5) Links to About, Contact and Privacy Policy pages at the very bottom.

No custom graphics or complicated CSS ... no reason to show the page itself dude. Won't be turning over kw lists either.

My point in this post was simply that getting other well-paid marketing people to do product research for me has paid off yet again. It has in the past, such as in the example of using the "Dummies" new releases for niche inspiration (think about it: they no doubt have a paid research staff and probably have books already written that are released along the timeline that the market research guys dictate -- they don't just see something in yesterday's news and say "OH SHIT WE GOTTA WRITE A BOOK ABOUT THAT QUICK!") A lot of marketers seem to have problems focusing on a niche this post was just meant to share one way to get inspired.


Frank
 
  • Like
Reactions: alexb
Status
Not open for further replies.