Anyone sick of scrubs? We are.

You guys cause the scrubbing yourself by talking about it on a public forum. Most of these direct response marketers involved in the free trial plus S/H model know nothing about shaving/scrubbing etc...
I don't think that's the case. Half the companies with Google Cash offers are the same companies that had grant offers. They don't seem to me to be newbies.
And beyond that, it should absolutely be talked about in a public forum.
What all of you are experiencing is credit card processing issues. That is it. Say Wachovia decides on Friday they dont like Acai companies anymore, and all of a sudden a customer of Wachovia decides to buy Acai and Wachovia goes, for your own good we are blocking this charge, there is one less conversion and what you think is scrubbing.
While this is the case some of the time, I don't honestly believe that an offer can go from 15%+ to 2-3% from one company blacklisting. Losing 80% of the conversions overnight?
Visa themselves could blacklist a company and you probably wouldn't lose 80%.
Most of these advertisers do not have access to their thank you pages due to PCI compliance so they cant remove or mess with the tracking pixel.
When an offer tanks move on to an different advertiser, chances are their MID's are havng issues, not that they are scrubbing.

And not for nothing i think smaxor and I may be the only two on this forum who understand this model inside and out from an advertiser perspective, a network perspective and an affiliate perspective.
Its not scrubbing by the advertiser but scrubbing by the credit card companies.
I agree that you do(on a side note, thanks for stepping into these heated discussions).
I've had my credit card frauded into a few free trial offers before, and noticed that the merchant accounts were numbered and somewhat obscure. So don't these guys have a rotation of accounts going on to resist blacklisting?
And beyond that, one thing I'll point out: If networks policed their lead-based campaigns to any reasonable level, affiliates probably wouldn't be so quick to assume that these free trial campaigns were shaving the piss out of us.

We're not being irrational; it's a conditioned response based on experience.
 


You guys cause the scrubbing yourself by talking about it on a public forum.
So which is it? Advertisers are too dense to scrub until we wise them up with complaints on public forums, or they don't scrub at all?

Seems it can't be both ways. Either some scrub or they do not. If we're causing the scrubbing, then that seems to undermine the argument that it is not happening, yes?
 
I don't think that's the case. Half the companies with Google Cash offers are the same companies that had grant offers. They don't seem to me to be newbies.
And beyond that, it should absolutely be talked about in a public forum.

While this is the case some of the time, I don't honestly believe that an offer can go from 15%+ to 2-3% from one company blacklisting. Losing 80% of the conversions overnight?
Visa themselves could blacklist a company and you probably wouldn't lose 80%.

I agree that you do(on a side note, thanks for stepping into these heated discussions).
I've had my credit card frauded into a few free trial offers before, and noticed that the merchant accounts were numbered and somewhat obscure. So don't these guys have a rotation of accounts going on to resist blacklisting?
And beyond that, one thing I'll point out: If networks policed their lead-based campaigns to any reasonable level, affiliates probably wouldn't be so quick to assume that these free trial campaigns were shaving the piss out of us.

We're not being irrational; it's a conditioned response based on experience.

It is possible to drop so dramatically if they were TMF'ed by their processor and have to change processors.

I agree some might scrub but most don't know what scrubbing is.

In bus opp you have a few guys who have been in the space a long time so those people might scrub, i dont disagree that advertisers scrub, but its not as wide spread as other offers or verticals.
 
I'm not promoting bizopps at the moment but I had to chime in. We cause the scrubbing by talking about it? Give me a fucking break. Who actually believes this? What is it, the heissenberg scrubbing principle?

If the merchant's credit card processing system goes down, a second after the merchant realizes this, all the affiliates who promote the offer should be notified. That way the affiliates don't keep losing money on something that can't be bought. Since the merchant can't take sales anyway, they should be up for doing that without any questions if there is a way to do it that is easy.
 
I'm not promoting bizopps at the moment but I had to chime in. We cause the scrubbing by talking about it? Give me a fucking break. Who actually believes this? What is it, the heissenberg scrubbing principle?

If the merchant's credit card processing system goes down, a second after the merchant realizes this, all the affiliates who promote the offer should be notified. That way the affiliates don't keep losing money on something that can't be bought. Since the merchant can't take sales anyway, they should be up for doing that without any questions if there is a way to do it that is easy.

A lot of advertisers read this board, they see everyone talk about scrubbing and think to themselves hmmm maybe i should try that.

Thats how talking about it causes it. Just like no one talks about their traffic sources out of fear of others copying, dont kid yourself in to thinking the shaving/scrubbing is not caused in some part by discussing it. You give advertisers ideas they will take them just like affiliates take the ideas they read about here.
 
A lot of advertisers read this board, they see everyone talk about scrubbing and think to themselves hmmm maybe i should try that.

Shit, with all the interest in merchant accounts and 'running your own offer' on here I should write an ebook. - How to scrub & make monies online as a merchant

I could even make it a rebill!

Note: I don't run my own offer (which makes me more than qualified to write an ebook), so please don't send me PM's on how to do it.
 
I agree with Mike. Most of our continuity advertisers don't even know what scrubbing/shaving means. Affiliate marketing is just a marketing channel in a larger marketing picture. Including outbound calling, direct mail, radio, etc. And like I said before if you were going to scrub you wouldn't scrub from 15% to 2-3% as you know you'd lose the business. Something broke. Think logically.
 
I agree with Mike. Most of our continuity advertisers don't even know what scrubbing/shaving means. Affiliate marketing is just a marketing channel in a larger marketing picture. Including outbound calling, direct mail, radio, etc. And like I said before if you were going to scrub you wouldn't scrub from 15% to 2-3% as you know you'd lose the business. Something broke. Think logically.

yup. I don't understand how affiliates think an advertiser is giving them 15% CR and then dropping it to 2-3% thinking the affiliates will KEEP sending traffic..
come on
 
You guys cause the scrubbing yourself by talking about it on a public forum. Most of these direct response marketers involved in the free trial plus S/H model know nothing about shaving/scrubbing etc...

What all of you are experiencing is credit card processing issues. That is it. Say Wachovia decides on Friday they dont like Acai companies anymore, and all of a sudden a customer of Wachovia decides to buy Acai and Wachovia goes, for your own good we are blocking this charge, there is one less conversion and what you think is scrubbing.

Most of these advertisers do not have access to their thank you pages due to PCI compliance so they cant remove or mess with the tracking pixel.

When an offer tanks move on to an different advertiser, chances are their MID's are havng issues, not that they are scrubbing.

And not for nothing i think smaxor and I may be the only two on this forum who understand this model inside and out from an advertiser perspective, a network perspective and an affiliate perspective.

Its not scrubbing by the advertiser but scrubbing by the credit card companies.

owned
 
yup. I don't understand how affiliates think an advertiser is giving them 15% CR and then dropping it to 2-3% thinking the affiliates will KEEP sending traffic..
come on

It happens a lot. I've seen biz ops convert at 12-18% for weeks straight and then drop to 1-6% over night and stay at that. The last time I witnessed this, it was probably because the advertiser got their quarterly earnings and didn't like where they were, so they basically started shaving the shit out of leads. At least that's my theory.
 
Dolddigga - your arguments suck major balls. It must be nice to live in your Mary Poppins fantasy land where everyone is nice and flogs do not yet exist.

Wake up.

The only ones living in a fantasy world are the douchebags who think networks and advertisers should cater to their whims while they offer nothing in exchange. I never said you can't use a flog, splog or other shady method of generating traffic...but you shouldn't be complaining here once you get raped right back. :)

But Networks, though their hearts are generally in the right place, have proved unwilling or unable to police advertisers in any meaningful way.

So what else can we do?
The rules of the thread I started are pretty strict. Hopefully that can reign in the insanity. The fact is that we don't have the data/phone numbers to tell 100% if they're shaving leads. The networks DO have the data, and DO have the phone numbers, and do jack shit. I'm pissed off and tired of it.


With all the trustworthy people who are sure to look out for each other rather than themselves, this idea is SURE to work! :)
/sarcasm

See if there are any offers that sell you a coffin, and give you a free hammer and a lifetime supply of nails (just pay shipping).

this

if you are producing quality leads in any vertical, you should be able to find someone who is willing to buy those at a fair price, and everyone wins. If you are good at it, you should be better than the advertiser is, even with their built in pricing advantage, so you yourself should be effectively creating value which you can sell.

The thing about lead pricing is that the market determines the value of the lead. "It's not worth what you think it's worth; it's worth whatever someone is willing to pay."

your an idiot. get out

The most intelligent response to date...and it's from what seems to be a transvestite. Sticky this now! :eek:
 
Getting pretty serious in here. If you think an advertiser is scrubbing/shaving, run a different offer. Many times I've seen EPC dive, just to return to normal the next day. I just split test multiple offers, pick a winner and run it til it dies, then back to split testing. There's been a lot of new offers and advertisers popping up in bizop, plenty to choose from. If you're trying to say it's too much work to potentially earn thousands of dollars a day, maybe you're in the wrong industry.
 
Jesus Christ.. this whining fest topic again?! I remember giving a pretty good breakdown of how the game works for almost all sides involved and why you dopes who complain so much shouldn't always point fingers at the networks or advertisers because the fact is, everyone is to blame at some point.

The short story to all of this is that no industry is perfect or honest, because when the name of the game is "who can make as much cash as quickly as possible" there will always be a few people on each side trying to make a lil more cash than the other guy and coming up with all sorts of creative ways just to make that extra buck. Sometimes it pays off, but usually it doesn't, especially in a longterm plan.

A lot of advertisers shave. This is very true in our industry. Some of them may not even realize they are doing it because they are following a protocol that was standard in say infomercial advertising or mail-order, etc. Obviously our rules are different, and since there are pretty much no rules or regulations to follow, everyone just does what they think is good for their business. Simple as that.

The advertisers that do know what they are doing, in terms of shaving, are almost always going to give you some obvious bullshit excuse and try to make it sound legitimate. If they are only shaving a little, most networks just let it slide, especially if the offer is converting well and the advertiser pays on time, you know, just the cost of doing business. For the advertisers who shave a lot or are brand new to that network, typically it doesn't take very long until that advertiser is kicked out of the network or if the network is really leniant, they just cap them and keep a real close eye on them. Don't blame the networks, because they have to constantly deal with asshole advertisers who try and fuck them over by not paying at all or delaying payment for months but still demand lots more leads or sales. But that's a whole 'nother story and I'm sure plenty of network owners here can shed light on that fuck fest at another time.

Another reason why advertisers have begun to shave a bit more lately is because affiliates put a lot of stress on the networks to pay them weekly or threaten to just jump ship to another network instead. Thus causing the advertiser to be able to float a significant amount of cash before they are able to go over the results of the campaign in a timely fashion that they are used to. So they probably figure "Well, if we have to pay you fuckers $300k a week after only 7 days from when the leads/trial sales came in, then we're going to cover our ass just a bit and skim a few points off the top just in case the quality sucks" -- Not a bad way to justify it either.

As an advertiser, you've also got a shitload of affiliates/networks constantly demanding that their leads are "quality". Just because they use quality traffic sources such as Adwords, MSN or Yahoo for PPC and media buys through MSN, AOL or whoever else doesn't mean that the traffic is quality, it just means that the sources are legit. I mean seriously now, how the fuck can any affiliate prove that the traffic really does result in quality customers that convert from trial to paid member? For all we know, there are 50,000 pedophiles that decided to converge onto AOL's properties for a month straight and click and fill out every fucking advertisement they see, you know, just to get back at society for hating them so much.

I mean, while that scenario is highly unlikely and all, how do you guys know that quality people are buying into this shit and won't just go onto ripoffreport or something and whine and bitch about how the trial they opted into is now stealing money from their bank account every month, magically of course! You don't know, so enough of this "I send quality leads" bullshit, because you don't know unless you get to see the data from the advertisers (which I think we may have to someday get to that point, where the advertisers and networks are scrutinized and have to show data reports to affiliates or risk losing that "quality traffic" stream altogether) -- But hopefully that doesn't happen anytime soon. It will though if everyone insists on continuing to fuck eachother left and right so rampantly without think and taking into concideration about the longterm effects or the ripple effects that are caused when each different side and component continue with their bullshit!

See, as an advertiser myself, I was a pissed off affiliate for a very long time. No matter what happened, I was always getting fucked. You'd think that being the owner of a forum like WickedFire that wouldn't happen to you, but it did, all the fuckin time! Even as a huge affiliate, still got fucked over by networks and advertisers. SO, I decided to do something about it. Instead I said fuck this, took on a trusted partner who is also a super duper fuckin affiliate himself and we made our own offers. But we took it a step further. Instead of being an idiot advertiser like the rest, we depend on ourselves, our connections, our credit, and our expertise on ALWAYS getting 95% of the traffic to our offers IN-HOUSE. The remaining 5% we get from networks that we trust. We also decided from the beginning to ALWAYS be 100% FTC compliant with our offer LP's so we don't have to encounter any legal issues from the feds. We did lots of other shit that no advertiser would ever do because they all claimed "it was bad for profits", but we knew it worked, and didn't have a problem spending more cash than the other guys to play it safe. Because we're in it for the long haul. We're not the highest paying advertiser either, nor are we the highest converting, but we sure as hell are the safest bet to go with and well on our way to become one of the largest ex-affiliates to become advertisers in the shortest amount of time, but thats because I have a giant cock and I'm just cool like that.

Sooooooo... with all of that said.. this thread, like the others bitching about god knows what or why this or that happens or how you're always getting fucked solves.. NOTHING. If you're getting fucked, how about you change the scenario so that, yes this is a crazy idea, YOU DON'T GET FUCKED ANYMORE! Bottom line, this industry is going to be going through some major changes in the next 1-2 years. The question is are you strong enough to survive and continue on, and work out the problems you're having now or just whither away with the masses?

Bye.
 
Right on ^^^

I accept scrubbing. I call it leakage. I'm an emailer, our profit margins are enormous. If I have to settle for 80% profit margins vs 90%, it's not the end of the world.

For you PPCs (and thats 99% of you), I understand your margins are nowhere near mine. I certainly wouldnt be running any offers where your margins are too small. And if you only know how to do Google LPs and that type of niche, you best realize soon there are other hot niches and offers out there from reputable Advertisers that are shaving to a tolerable degree. Yes, a tolerable degree.

Find something you can live with, make a killing, have backup offers in place so you can switch without a hitch and not bitch.

/poetic license
 
Jesus Christ.. this whining fest topic again?! I remember giving a pretty good breakdown of how the game works for almost all sides involved and why you dopes who complain so much shouldn't always point fingers at the networks or advertisers because the fact is, everyone is to blame at some point.

The short story to all of this is that no industry is perfect or honest, because when the name of the game is "who can make as much cash as quickly as possible" there will always be a few people on each side trying to make a lil more cash than the other guy and coming up with all sorts of creative ways just to make that extra buck. Sometimes it pays off, but usually it doesn't, especially in a longterm plan.

A lot of advertisers shave. This is very true in our industry. Some of them may not even realize they are doing it because they are following a protocol that was standard in say infomercial advertising or mail-order, etc. Obviously our rules are different, and since there are pretty much no rules or regulations to follow, everyone just does what they think is good for their business. Simple as that.

The advertisers that do know what they are doing, in terms of shaving, are almost always going to give you some obvious bullshit excuse and try to make it sound legitimate. If they are only shaving a little, most networks just let it slide, especially if the offer is converting well and the advertiser pays on time, you know, just the cost of doing business. For the advertisers who shave a lot or are brand new to that network, typically it doesn't take very long until that advertiser is kicked out of the network or if the network is really leniant, they just cap them and keep a real close eye on them. Don't blame the networks, because they have to constantly deal with asshole advertisers who try and fuck them over by not paying at all or delaying payment for months but still demand lots more leads or sales. But that's a whole 'nother story and I'm sure plenty of network owners here can shed light on that fuck fest at another time.

Another reason why advertisers have begun to shave a bit more lately is because affiliates put a lot of stress on the networks to pay them weekly or threaten to just jump ship to another network instead. Thus causing the advertiser to be able to float a significant amount of cash before they are able to go over the results of the campaign in a timely fashion that they are used to. So they probably figure "Well, if we have to pay you fuckers $300k a week after only 7 days from when the leads/trial sales came in, then we're going to cover our ass just a bit and skim a few points off the top just in case the quality sucks" -- Not a bad way to justify it either.

As an advertiser, you've also got a shitload of affiliates/networks constantly demanding that their leads are "quality". Just because they use quality traffic sources such as Adwords, MSN or Yahoo for PPC and media buys through MSN, AOL or whoever else doesn't mean that the traffic is quality, it just means that the sources are legit. I mean seriously now, how the fuck can any affiliate prove that the traffic really does result in quality customers that convert from trial to paid member? For all we know, there are 50,000 pedophiles that decided to converge onto AOL's properties for a month straight and click and fill out every fucking advertisement they see, you know, just to get back at society for hating them so much.

I mean, while that scenario is highly unlikely and all, how do you guys know that quality people are buying into this shit and won't just go onto ripoffreport or something and whine and bitch about how the trial they opted into is now stealing money from their bank account every month, magically of course! You don't know, so enough of this "I send quality leads" bullshit, because you don't know unless you get to see the data from the advertisers (which I think we may have to someday get to that point, where the advertisers and networks are scrutinized and have to show data reports to affiliates or risk losing that "quality traffic" stream altogether) -- But hopefully that doesn't happen anytime soon. It will though if everyone insists on continuing to fuck eachother left and right so rampantly without think and taking into concideration about the longterm effects or the ripple effects that are caused when each different side and component continue with their bullshit!

See, as an advertiser myself, I was a pissed off affiliate for a very long time. No matter what happened, I was always getting fucked. You'd think that being the owner of a forum like WickedFire that wouldn't happen to you, but it did, all the fuckin time! Even as a huge affiliate, still got fucked over by networks and advertisers. SO, I decided to do something about it. Instead I said fuck this, took on a trusted partner who is also a super duper fuckin affiliate himself and we made our own offers. But we took it a step further. Instead of being an idiot advertiser like the rest, we depend on ourselves, our connections, our credit, and our expertise on ALWAYS getting 95% of the traffic to our offers IN-HOUSE. The remaining 5% we get from networks that we trust. We also decided from the beginning to ALWAYS be 100% FTC compliant with our offer LP's so we don't have to encounter any legal issues from the feds. We did lots of other shit that no advertiser would ever do because they all claimed "it was bad for profits", but we knew it worked, and didn't have a problem spending more cash than the other guys to play it safe. Because we're in it for the long haul. We're not the highest paying advertiser either, nor are we the highest converting, but we sure as hell are the safest bet to go with and well on our way to become one of the largest ex-affiliates to become advertisers in the shortest amount of time, but thats because I have a giant cock and I'm just cool like that.

Sooooooo... with all of that said.. this thread, like the others bitching about god knows what or why this or that happens or how you're always getting fucked solves.. NOTHING. If you're getting fucked, how about you change the scenario so that, yes this is a crazy idea, YOU DON'T GET FUCKED ANYMORE! Bottom line, this industry is going to be going through some major changes in the next 1-2 years. The question is are you strong enough to survive and continue on, and work out the problems you're having now or just whither away with the masses?

Bye.
So I had a reply to you, but it was actually too long to post. I'll summarize with a smaller list(not threaded anymore):
-There's accountability for the affiliate.
-There's accountability to an extent for the network.
-There's none for the advertiser(which we actually tried to do in this thread, though it doesn't seem like you noticed that)

-Dealing with the advertisers is the networks job. It's what they fucking do. Why would we give them a cut if they're not doing this? Yeah it's hard. But that's why they make money for it.

-I'm not stupid. I know when my leads are good and when they're piss. When I've been told of the quality, it's pretty much always where I thought it'd be.
-The entire reason we send people to THEIR site is so they have a chance to inform/prequalify the user. Otherwise we'd all be using whitelabels.

-We all know the industry is changing, and we're trying to position ourselves in a way to not get fucked, but until then, us bitching IS us trying not to get fucked.
-What you call "bitching" has done a LOT of positive things for affiliates. Do you remember the companies that we've brought fucking hell to? That all started with bitching.