Does YouTube scan/rip/upload to their site?

zimok

Click, Whirr.
Oct 27, 2008
2,391
99
0
Canada... eh!
One of my friends owns a large site very similar to YouTube. Last month and months preceding the googlebot slurped his site for 50gb+ of data. Yahoo/MSN crawlers don't even compare(less than 1gb on average). We all know google can't extrapolate a lot of data from mediums other than text.

The basic conspiracy is: YouTube analyzes his site for unique content and automatically uploads it to YouTube.

How the theory came up: He ripped a series of very old French cartoons off VHS tapes, within 24 hours they were on YouTube (subsequent uploads to other tube sites like metacafe etc.. took much much longer, and looked more 'natural').

He's trying to devise some more advanced tracking at the moment and I suggested he tried this to see if he's right,

1. Upload 10 absolutely unique videos on his site, unique description, identifiers etc..

2. Upload 10 videos ripped off YouTube using a same quality rip, descriptions etc..

3. Look at tracking to see if the 10 unique videos were scraped/uploaded, and the 10 ripped off ones not touched.

I'm posting this here to see if anyone else owns some tube sites and had similar experiences? We know he can simply block the crawler but that's besides the point, I just want to know if this technique is being used. I really can't think of any other reason why Google would crawl his site for that amount of data every month.

Maybe this is old news, but I never heard about it and tried some basic searches on google and found no mention of this technique being used by Google.
 


It could be one of his competitors using a spider that names itself as a googlebot so not to raise suspicions.. That's just a theory, maybe compare the IP to known google crawlers?
 
It could be one of his competitors using a spider that names itself as a googlebot so not to raise suspicions.. That's just a theory, maybe compare the IP to known google crawlers?

Doesn't really apply, the videos were on YouTube and YouTube only.
 
What are the usernames of the videos on yt, do their profiles look similar to each other, when were they created, etc. That would be fucking dirty if google was doing that but I wouldn't put em past it.
 
doesn't mean it's not someone ripping the videos and posting them on their own youtube account.


QTF
theres programs that grab videos from other popular video sites rip them, usually put their link or something in the description unless they're trying to build up their youtube account and upload them to youtube.
It still sounds very suspicious though. Do some more tests and see what you can find.
 
Make 100 copies of the dickroll video and upload that. Chop a second or 2 and use different encoders. See if those end up on youtube.
 
Get a flash programmer to install some kind of tracking in your video player so you can monitor this. If they are scraping your videos this will be some nice link bait ;)