Just to be clear here you're the one who called the other PM tools, and services "college stack" and basically started calling names and saying people weren't doing it right from the get-go. You attempted to establish yourself as an authority, and I asked you about your stack. I didn't look at it as "calling you out" since you took it that way you must be rather insecure.
I'm trying not to make this personal, but if you keep replying so ignorantly you're really leaving yourself open
Step outside your bubble.
Have you come to realize not everyone is doing the SAME projects as you? Not all their needs or my needs align with yours. Do you have clients where you dedicate 1-3 contractors/employees full time that need to integrate with their company and existing management tools? Probably not or you'd know that public tools rarely work in any of these situations.
At no point was I "calling you out" I genuinely wanted to see your "ultimate stack" but it's turned out your ultimate stack changes based on the needs which I agree with... then you went off and say custom software for management isn't needed, and that we should all use public software because it's easier to learn. Doh...
Maybe your definition of "project" and mine aren't the same...
Did you think of that?
You're too glued to your beliefs based on your limited experiences, step out, and open your eyes that there is a ton more than just what "you do" being done out there.
I'm not using pre-built public management software to manage XYZ company projects that rely on YYYY software, we will integrate with YYYY with our own PM software, pull in the data and make things simple as fuck for my employees and contractors. When I used to offer PRs for my clients instead of throwing them all in baseCamp we made custom PR management software that handled the edits/revisions, orders, client requests, etc... it managed ALL the projects for that business.
If you fail to see how any of those examples benefit from a custom project management platform then I can't get through to you
Anyway, you've gone in circles attempting to prove you're an authority on project management tools while suggesting various tools over the last 1 year period of time for the same management solution. Maybe you're the confused one who needs help?
I don't have a dog in this fight because my management software isn't public, isn't for sale, and will never be. That doesn't mean it will work for you, or anyone but it sure as hell works for me and I'm not going to let someone new to the business try to tell others how shit is done when there's no RIGHT way to manage clients.
Go to business meetups, conferences, and start talking to other business owners you'll quickly learn your way is rarely the way anyone else does it, and that's "OK".