I'll probably be called gay for half of this, but these are some of the more obscure movies that I've watched and enjoyed lately.
Cheri
Gigantic
Synecdoche, New York
Two Lovers
Vicky, Cristina, Barcelona
The Wackness
Bruno
Or there's always the classics (to make me not seem as gay):
Office Space
Dumb and Dumber
40 Year Old Virgin
Grandma's Boy
Heat
Pulp Fiction
Shaun of The Dead
The Score
Scarface
Super Troopers
Superbad
Sin City
Or the semi recent:
Shooter
Eastern Promises
Running Scared
Lucky Number Slevin
Those are random from my netflix ratings 4-5 stars.