Nice post slayerment.
The gold VS fiat debate has plenty of arguments on both sides. The way I see it, however, is it comes down to whether you trust the government to regulate the money supply (fiat) or whether you trust the free market to regulate the money supply (gold).
This is true. And for me - I trust the U.S. government more for issuing and regulating a fiat money supply than the free market in maintaining a stable environment for gold/silver backed currency. We could go back and forth on whether this is right or wrong but world views are hard to argue against.
My view is that many Monied Interests are the root of all evil. Many will do anything they can to to get a little more money. Morals and collateral damage are not taken into consideration. In a barely regulated pure free market the monied interests have a much easier time doing their damage and reaping the rewards. With regulations and government in the way they have a harder time.. but yes of course it's still taking place.. but to a lesser degree than if government was not there at all regulating things.
Path of Least Resistance: Elites -> Profit/Damage
Path of Most Resistance: Elites -> U.S. Government Infiltration -> Profit/Damage
The path of least resistance will cause the most damage in the long run.
So unlike modern tea-party members or republicans I don't think we should be chanting "less government" all the time, I think we should be chanting "optimal government".
Still's main argument is that a gold-backed currency is open for manipulation. This is absolutely true. BUT SO IS A FREAKING FIAT CURRENCY! Even more so.
I'd argue gold/silver supply is much more easily manipulated than a government issued fiat currency. But not all governments are equal. That's why I keep saying I trust U.S. government issued currency more.
Also, gold/silver backed currency makes it much easier for foreign nations and other possible enemies to manipulate our currency than government issued fiat currency.
All fiat currencies eventually end up going to their true value of zero.
Since almost all modern currencies are fiat, this is obviously false or unprovable at best.
And this usually only happens to older fiat currencies after that form of fiat currency has officially been declared invalid for taxes and is converted into another form of currency. There is usually a transition. Often one form of fiat will transition into another form of fiat. And that's actually the way it will likely happen from here on out in modern civilization - unless there's a full out apocalypse destroying a significant portion of the population and taking modern civilization with it. Then, I agree, gold and silver coins would be great.