Shoot holes in my business plan

johnmatrix

New member
Jan 4, 2008
1,958
31
0
Because I'm pretty convinced it can't fail. Starting from the top, I own an online store selling jewellery, it does alright purely online.. I get a ROI from facebook advertising amazingly. I have been in the jewellery business for about 3 years so I know what people like. I have since been attempting to get my range of products which are actually very unique and much loved by everyone that sees them, into retail stores on a consignment basis. Consignment, for those that don't know, is when a store takes my products for no upfront cost, and if they sell an item they take a cut of the sale price and I get the rest. So far I have made two deals.

I set the retail price of the items and the stores takes 40% of that. I want to make it worth their time.

1. First store is a local custom jewellery store, the guy there mainly does custom made wedding rings and stuff like that, my line has been in there for about 8 months now. On average I get about $300 a month in profit from that store after he takes his commission and I take out my expenses. This store does not get a lot of foot traffic and he is very often closed during the week because his main business is by appointment.

2. Second store is a new jewellery shop that opened up in my suburb, it gets a shit-tonne of foot traffic, they have been in there for a month and a half and my profit so far is $966 after expenses and subtracting the stores commission. This one is obviously much more productive than the other one. My items are in the store window and the couple that runs it are extremely friendly and easy going, it's perfect.

Based on these figures... My goal now is to get deals with 10 stores which I believe would be a very easy task. These first 2 stores were easy to convince and my products basically sold themselves on first glance. Earlier on I visited two different stores, one wanted me to provide a lockable cabinet, packaging for the products (which I didn't have at the time), he was very demanding and I didn't get a good vibe. I never bothered to go back there. The other store wanted them too but It was just down the road from the number 2 jewellery store listed above that is selling them now, so a bit too close for comfort. Either way it shows it is not hard to convince stores to give them a try. It's nothing out of their pocket at the start, and if they sell they make money. If they don't sell, they haven't lost anything and the stock still belongs to me. It's a win-win situation.

Based on the current stores, I estimate on average each will generate me a conservative profit of $400 a month, that's $4000 a month profit from 10 stores without me having to do a damn thing apart from invoicing and restocking them. About the average salary of a 9-5 schmuck.

The only downside to this consignment approach is that it ties up a lot of my stock, I have to provide say 10 styles of items and there's 6 sizes of each. 60 Items per store. This will cost me about $500 in stock per store. Basically the first month should cover my investment and from there it is highly profitable even after restocking. The stock still belongs to me if it doesn't sell anyway. I could take the wholesale approach but I think it would be harder to sell to shops since they actually have to invest money in my stuff at the start and I would have to sell it cheaper than the 60% highly profitable cut I get from consignment.

The sky is the limit... 10 stores = $4000 a month, 30 stores = $16,000 a month for doing very little work, just the way I like it. Visit once a month, count what has been sold, invoice them and off I go.

Is there anything I'm missing here?
 


well this is of course if your jewelry continues to sell. I don't know how much of the operation you run or what you outsource but it sounds like a solid enough plan. Make sure you map out every possible expense. The bigger you get the better the money but a lot more responsibilities.

Unless you can outsource 90% of your work your most likely going to be a 9-5 worker by going this route but at least you will have a nice opening and pretty stable offline business. Can't beat that.
 
Is consignment widespread? do only mom and pop shops do them? how large can you grow before they track down your supplier and cut you out? (if they would)
 
Some random thoughts:

- If tying up stock is a problem, pull your stock out of store #1 that is closed a lot of the time and only making $300 a month, and try to find another store making $900 per month, like store #2.
- to make $4k per month, don't get 10 stores giving you $400 per month, try to find 4 stores giving you $1k per month. Less work to collect from 4 stores monthly then 10.
- Once you reach a certain mass, try to find a sales person to sign up new stores for you. Offer them a one time payment of $xxx if they sign up a new store, and maybe even some kind of ongoing % of profit for say 6 months to make them want to sign up quality stores. Or some variation of that, but basically get help doing business development once you can afford it.
 
Once a store's been doing consignment for a while, offer them a slightly better deal if they pay up front? Or simply tell them you won't do consignment anymore? Or 50/50?

I'm sure you could work out a better deal once they've been making money selling your products.
 
Once a store's been doing consignment for a while, offer them a slightly better deal if they pay up front? Or simply tell them you won't do consignment anymore? Or 50/50?

I'm sure you could work out a better deal once they've been making money selling your products.

The only reason you should be doing consignment in the first place is to "prove" to the owner that your product will sell. Must explain this up front to begin with, so they know that after a set time period if they want the product to continue being in their store they must buy. Otherwise you will be in a "being walked all over" situation like OP.

...and to OP: Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like the whole reason for you starting this thread is to find reasons why you can't go out and land 10 more stores yourself. Amirite?

...so my real advice to you would be:
Keep hanging in there, someone will come up with a really great scheme which involves you doing no actual work, and your shitty jewelry will magically be in 10 stores by this time tomorrow.
 
fuck, that came off as pretty harsh... alcohol fffffffffffuuuuuuuuuuuu

...anyways I'm just basing the above comments off of personal experience, currently dealing with a few of the OP's issues... successfully negotiated others (recently). It's a learning curve, that's for sure, every business operates differently, many of them require "creative" sales tactics.
 
What stops you from having more stock? Funding? Or time to manufacture?

+1 on pulling stock from slow store and putting it in a store than can move it faster. If you are trying to create funds to grow, you should do it as fast as possible. Once stock is not a problem you could go back to the slow store.
 
It's not clear, to me at least whether you're manufacturing the stock, or buying it from someone else, either way -

If you are making it yourself this presumably takes time, and I'd say a lot of it if you're supplying 10 stores - start to look at how you can outsource this for less.

If you're buying it from someone else - going from a grand or so a month to 10 grand is not going to go unnoticed by either the original manufacturer and other distributors in your market.

The manufacturer may not realise the demand in their product and once proven could look for a major retail distribution firm who supply 10s of thousands of stores. Your retailers and other people in the game may also look for ways to cut you out.

Look to lock down an exclusive distribution deal and some discount for volume. If you're not on credit terms with the supplier start negotiating this as well.

Also - if you're really confident and the manufacture is under valuing the scope of the product range you may look to purchase this out right.

And start thinking about streamlining distribution - online ordering and cheap reliable shipping.
 
yo yer bizness plan has more holes than swiss chess mother fucka!!

...just kid man it was 2 long 2 read
 
You must be crazy man. You might have been able to turn a profit on jewelry a few years ago, but now everyone is cashing in cause of the recession.

Haven't you seen Dollas4Gold broham?

This plan simply doesn't have long-term potential unless your planning on selling bling-wear like dollar bill pendants and big ass chains to the rich rappers.
 
^-- lol.

In the end, it doesn't matter what any of us say here. You've proven you can turn a profit on 2 stores, so rather than taking the advice of others without direct experience in your market, get off the computer right now and make more deals.
 
Looks like your problem is having too much initial inventory tied up, possibly in an underperforming store? Then just scale a little more slowly.

If you're making the product yourself - just work it.

shoot for a few big accounts rather than many small ones
keep pushing for better credit terms from your suppliers
start sourcing direct if possible
hire someone to make the products

The only holes we've run into is getting sick of making your product & being chained to the business, or not finding enough wholesale accounts. The first is emotional and can be dealt with. The second, well...just do it.

Worst that happens is you run an inventory surplus for a few months, can't find as many big accounts to grab, but if your product is moving it will even out soon enough.
 
You must be crazy man. You might have been able to turn a profit on jewelry a few years ago, but now everyone is cashing in cause of the recession.

Haven't you seen Dollas4Gold broham?

This plan simply doesn't have long-term potential unless your planning on selling bling-wear like dollar bill pendants and big ass chains to the rich rappers.

Notice the his spelling of Jewellery? He is in the UK
 
You can also hire a salesman to go from store to store and pay them out another 20%. You gonna make less, but then you also don't have to do anything. The salesman shall also maintain stock and do day to day store support and continue the operation running. You can reuse the same model in other cities, once you perfect it in your own city.
 
Cheers fellas, some good shit here. To clear some things up... might be a long one.

- I see no reason why my jewellery would cease to sell, they are very conservative pieces appealing to a wide audience. No fad bling stuff.

- I do not make the jewellery myself, I source it directly from manufacturers overseas already. I am a small fish to them at the moment. I have become quite good friends with one of the salesmen at my original manufacturer, he actually quit his job to start his own company and I've been dealing with him directly ever since. He sources me the highest quality stuff at the best price. I basically pick 20 pieces out of a catalog of 500... I also get many items made to my specifications so they are unique to my business.

- I am actually waiting for stock at the moment which is what made me start this thread, the lead time is at least a month. I have about 600 pieces on order and and I have a few hundred more in stock already here which are reserved for my online store. Therefore I will have plenty to go around 10+ stores, stock isn't a problem as long as I order it early enough.

- For stores to cut me out and to track down my suppliers would not be an easy feat. I am giving them a generous 40%, they don't have to do anything except collect the monies. Compare that to dealing with suppliers that can't speak english, an enormous amount of shitty low quality stuff out there, international money transfers, 1 month lead times on orders, minimum order quantities of *50* per size per style which equals about 300 items just to get a decent range of sizes for ONE style (my MOQ is much lower because I know the guy well enough), the 15% import duty, it soon becomes very restrictive and expensive. In the beginning I ordered from different suppliers, sometimes items I received looked like cheap knockoffs of the pictures in their own catalogues probably because they just stole the catalogues from other suppliers... It's not easy to find the genuine quality stuff without connections.

- An estimate of $400 per month profit is me being very conservative. In reality I believe if I pick the right stores (such as the the 2nd jewellery store I mentioned) it will be much higher. $400 works out to be around 6 items sold in a month, it's really not a high figure.

- Someone mentioned using consignment as like a trial run to prove the shit sells, and then move to a wholesale model from there. That is definitely do-able, I would have to offer them a lower price though.. in the long run I will make less doing wholesale than what I would make from consignment. I am not locked down though, if a store wants to go wholesale I'm happy to negotiate that with them. They would be looking at an initial investment of around $4000 to cover all the sizes and a good range of styles.

So at the moment I am preparing everything to blitz a whole bunch of stores while I wait for the stock to arrive in the next week or 2. A lot of things do crop up that you don't immediately realise, as I explained in my original post, another store I approached wanted packaging and a display cabinet.. shit I never considered at the time that I now have under control.

I have put together:
- Paper catalogues to drop off at stores.
- Spreadsheet for the stores to keep track of sales in an easy way.
- Invoice template for me to bill them.
- A way of packaging the 60+ items the stores have to carry in a logical and easily accessible way, only one size of each style will be on display so they have another 50 or so items "in the back", can't just give them to them in a plastic bag. It has to be easy and professional for when customers want to try on different sizes.
- A way of me tracking exactly how much and which stock each store carries. I will eventually develop a php\mysql web interface to track all that so I can just visit the store with my laptop, punch in what has sold and it will update the stock levels in the database then generate an invoice for the store. I love doing that shit.
- A simple contract stating the terms of the agreement.

The actual deals should be the easy part.. in theory.
 
Consignment is how things are done in the jewelry world.

Sounds good to me. Go for it Johnny. Good luck too.
 
so you are asking if a product, that somehow will always sell and sell in as many stores as you place it is a bad business plan to expand?

Why not hire 20 sales guys and get 20,000 stores. You will make $8 mil per month (20,000 x $400).

The reality is that just because 2 boutique stores sold a couple thousand dollars of you stuff, does not necessarily mean they can sell more, or all stores can sell your product.

If your product is that amazing, sell way more of it.
 
You're missing a 30k personal loan from your local bank.

Apply for that and build not 10, but 1000 stores.

Why limit yourself?