Phase 2: Evaluating the options
The evaluation process is simply to take each of the options (quadrants) and
systematically enquire how effective a strategy it represents for moving towards
your business objectives. In evaluating the options, the first question to ask is: How
far can we get as we are?
Having completed your SWOT analysis, the answer will be partly dependent
on your evaluation of the relative weightings you have given to your competitive
strengths and weaknesses, and in particular to your analysis of the following factors:
1 The distinctiveness of your business in the minds of your customers (which
must be founded on hard evidence, not the product of your beliefs alone).
2 Yourkeystrengthsvis-`a-vis your weaknesses (the former should outweigh the
latter comfortably and your plans to eliminate or ameliorate the latter should be
actionable without exceptional cost or organizational energy).
3 Countervailing forces in the market (which should not pose an insurmountable
threat).
4 The probability of opportunities and threats affecting your business within
the timescale of your business plan (this might require further research or
investigation).
Unless there are many factors in this analysis forcing you to change the way you
do business, you should be in a strong position to maintain your present strategy,
while making the usual marginal improvements to take action on the key points
in your SWOT analysis; in other words, to improve profitability by making the
business more efficient and effective. The main benefit of this penetration strategy
is that you can focus resources on the things you do best, allowing more time to look after existing customers, while continuing to build the business by organizing
to win new customers in existing market segments. While this should necessitate a
modest amount of reorganization, it does not constitute a change in strategy and is
therefore the least risky option.
On the other hand, your analysis might force you to consider cutting out parts of
your business. Changesmight encompass small-scale cutbacks to sales territories, or
swingeing changes to product lines and market segments, with internal resources
being retrenched at the same time. If your management information system is
sufficiently detailed (otherwise you will have to resort to ad hoc costing and
profitability calculations), you must cut out those parts of the business that lose
money and focus resources on those that generate profits. The net effect is an
increase in overall profitability, although a decrease in terms of sales value. This
could be a prelude to a later ‘go for growth’ strategy.
If your SWOT analysis points to one of the three ‘growth’ strategies as a serious
option, it should be evaluated more thoroughly. A methodical approach is called
for, testing each option against the same set of criteria, as follows.