What a fucking Nazi! (Sorry Dresden)
As a libertarian I do fully support his right to have the freedom to utter such insane rantings.
What a fucking Nazi! (Sorry Dresden)
Hmm, glad I didn't invest too much time in reading all of this thread...
If his idea of no government is such a great idea why has there never been a successful country / group of people that has done it before? Oh yea because they get shit on by another nation / government.
It doesn't work and it would hinder the advancement of the human race.
If everyone was free to do their own shit we would be living in huts, gathering food and wiping our asses with twigs. There would be no point in trying to advance ourselves because whats the point?
Thousands of years of past history should tell you that freedom of government just doesn't work because there will always be someone bigger than you ready to stomp on you. That's why government exists. So drop the idiotic idea that the world would be a utopia without it.
People like luke give the human species too much credit. He thinks we would all be peachy and live in harmony if we were all free. He's too stupid to realize its taken us thousands of years to get where we are and it had nothing to do with letting everyone be free and live their lives.
It must be great being a happy & content slave.
A slave? Really? How does paying taxes equate to this?
You anarchists act as if the world & life has shit all over you, and things are unbearably hard. All the while, we're actually enjoying a more prosperous and bountiful life than has ever been achieved by the human species in history.
You do understand that defense & security would still exist, right?
It must be great being a happy & content slave.
A slave? Really? How does paying taxes equate to this?
You anarchists act as if the world & life has shit all over you
...and things are unbearably hard.
All the while, we're actually enjoying a more prosperous and bountiful life than has ever been achieved in history by the human species.
It will? Who's going to pay for it? Will it be by donations or will you get a monthly bill for $162.78 for the military (your monthly share of the annual budget assuming every man, woman and child alive pays the same) to go along with your 127 other monthly bills?
If you pay annually, will they give you a discount like they do on car insurance? If you don't pay it, what happens to you? Do they send a collection agency after you? Do they garnish your wages? Do they eventually bring charges against you and throw you in jail? Sounds suspiciously like taxes to me.
Everyone is moaning about these services being "mandated". Will they not be mandated in your new utopian society? Or will they be purely voluntary? Do you get a menu of services that you can pick and choose which to pay from? Or do you just get the bills every month which you are expected to pay? If it's the former and no one decides to pay for certain services what happens then? Do those services go bankrupt and cease to exist? If it's the later then it's still mandated and there's not a whole lot of difference between what is happening now.
Is your sense of morality really so warped as to not see how the land owner would feel that this act is violent against them? Imagine if he were standing right there, at his property line as you pulled the truck up. Wouldn't dumping it on his line then make you an evildoer? Wouldn't he be upset?Who said anything about initiating violence? if I want to dump toxic chemicals why shouldn't I?
There can be a privatized EPA. Laws too work just fine under Anarchy.There's no EPA, there's no laws against dumping toxic chemicals.
Ignorance cannot be an excuse. If it were ANY society would crumble and fall.I didn't intend to hurt anybody, it's not my fault some kids with shit parents played in it. It's a free society right? What am I doing wrong?
And what makes you think they'll want to fight an army and risk their lives for a client of theirs who would obviously lose the court battle? You couldn't use private security for this... You'd have to pay the big bucks for Mercanaries who don't ask too many questions.No matter anyway, my private security force will fight the insurance company's private goons to the death since they have no more power over me than anybody else.
Oh really. Please enlighten us.You fucked up big time on this one.
The more you behave that way in such a society, the more the villagers will get restless and plot to remove you. It's a losing stance to take 100% of the time... Peace is the answer. Learn what the Non Aggression Principle is all about... You seem to equate anarchy with violence when in fact it is quite the opposite.So what? I'm armed to the teeth and I have private security. Come at me bro. I'll keep doing what I want because nobody has any authoritarian power over me. Especially with all my money, I can buy the biggest guns.
No, you are simply uneducated on this matter. Again, read about the non aggression principle. Stopping conflicts is easy if no one initiates the aggression.That is my point, you're complaining about the government threatening people with violence, yet your anarchist society does exactly the same thing, just with no accountability.
So you hear about security and you assume they are hitmen. Wow, talk about being uninformed.Ohhh, kick ass. So hitmen are legal, and you don't have to worry about that pesky evidence and trial stuff anymore. That actually does sound quite efficient! Instead of businesses busting ass to provide better value than the competition, they can just put a hit out on the competition. Much easier!
Please stop before you embarrass yourself too much.Huh? Wait... what??? So if the Mexico govt and police force didn't exist, there wouldn't be any drug gangs in Mexico, fighting over various areas (ie. markets of consumers)? You can't possibly believe that.
Now you're really reaching. Why not just ask me what's bigger than the Biggest?And when 100,000 foreign, blood thirsty soldiers show up, and murder everyone at Pinkertons?
I personally assume that anarchy can't survive a foreign governments' existence. Seasteads may be an exception but I doubt they could get very big while governments exist. The society I personally am speaking about can only be created once the people of the entire planet wake up and understand anarchy, which of course will take a little while or two. So there is no need to argue the point of foriegn invaders, there simply wouldn't be any.Sorry, but when the foreign military force shows up, I don't think they'll buy the, "sorry, we're anarchists and don't believe in violence" line.
Yep, I'm sure the --->GOVERNMENT FUNDED<--- private security companies are indeed very scary. It gives me nightmares thinking about their evils.These government funded, private security companies are scary indeed.
Do some research on Wackenhut.
Quite simply because we aren't free. No one is arguing that their masters didn't use more excessive force against them directly. (Of course our masters today DO kill thousands or millions of innocents every single year.)A slave? Really? How does paying taxes equate to this?
Wow, you're so blinded by the gilding on your shiny cage that you actually DESPISE freedom, don't you?You anarchists act as if the world & life has shit all over you, and things are unbearably hard. All the while, we're actually enjoying a more prosperous and bountiful life than has ever been achieved in history by the human species. Sure there's problems, and progress to be made, but dismantling everything, and dragging us back by hundreds of years probably isn't the solution.
We are going bankrupt. We are essentially living on a credit card. Productivity has slowed. Savings and capital are being attacked and discouraged on several fronts. This "prosperous and bountiful life" you speak of has been financed.
No, you are simply uneducated on this matter. Again, read about the non aggression principle. Stopping conflicts is easy if no one initiates the aggression.
How could gangs get their power & money if their product wasn't banned by the government and therefore made artificially expensive and worth committing murder for?
Quite simply because we aren't free.
Yes, the US, and various other Western nations are on the decline. There's also various areas in the world that are experiencing double digit GDP growth right now. Empires rise and fall -- that doesn't change the fact that from a historical perspective, us humans are currently enjoying an extremely high standard of living.
And an extremely high standard of Slavery to match.Empires rise and fall -- that doesn't change the fact that from a historical perspective, us humans are currently enjoying an extremely high standard of living.
Silly socialist, aggression is for your folk, not people who believe in the NAP.Oh man, but... just because you read something, doesn't make it a realistic possibility. You can't just gather around and say, "ok, no aggression allowed guys", and expect it to happen. And I highly doubt evolution is going to kick in within the next 10 years to make this a possibility either.
Wouldn't dream of it. But you think anarchy will take mankind in a direction he was never headed in, while I say it will lead mankind to simply keep on evolving in the direction he was going before Government placed chains around his neck.By nature, us humans can be quite greedy and vicious individuals, and like it or not, that's one of the many factors that's contributed to our advancement as a species. Call it a necessary evil. It's genetically programmed into us though, and you're not going to change it.
Wow, you just used a gang of drug and prostitution merchants to illustrate your point. You really don't have what it takes to get this, do you?For example, take the Hell's Angels. If they see a profitable area for drugs and/or prostitution that they'd like to control, they simply move in, and through force kick all existing gangs and drug dealers out of the area. Then settle in, monopolize, and charge whatever they want to the residents of that area. Only thing that would be accomplished by removing the police from the equation would be the process would become quicker, harsher, more violent, and more streamlined.
The best trick the devil ever did was convincing the world he doesn't exist. How can your standards get so low?Gotta say though, don't feel like a slave in the slightest right now. Sure I have to jump through some hoops with immigration, and pay taxes, but that's fine with me. I would rather pay one tax bill to a corrupt govt that's elected by the people every few years, versus paying 90 bills to private entities such as Goldman Sachs and Halliburton to provide the essential services.